Ethan Herisse

Elwood

Brandon Wilson

Turner

Aunjanue Ellis-Taylor

Hattie

Hamish Linklater

Spencer

Gralen Bryant Banks

Blakeley

Fred Hechinger

Harper

Jimmie Fails

Mr. Hill

Luke Tennie

Griff

Bryan Gael Guzman

Jaime

Daveed Diggs

Adult Elwood

Sam Malone

Percy

Najah Bradley

Evelyn

Taraja Ramsess

Rodney

Zach Primo

White Boy

Bryant Tardy

Desmond

Robert Aberdeen

Mr. Goodall

Escalante Lundy

Earl

Ja'Quan Monroe-Henderson

Black Mike

Rachel Whitman Groves

Nurse Scarlet

Billy Slaughter

Dr. Cooke

Lucy Faust

Mrs. Hardee

Tanyell Waivers

Denise

Craig Tate

Adult Chickie Pete

Sara Osi Scott

Millie

LeBaron Foster Thornton

Larry (uncredited)