Randolph Scott

Bat Masterson

Robert Ryan

Allen Harper

Anne Jeffreys

Ruby Stone

George 'Gabby' Hayes

Billy Jones

Madge Meredith

Susan Pritchett

Steve Brodie

Logan Maury

Billy House

Carmody

Virginia Sale

Hannah

Harry Woods

Larkin

Harry Harvey

Mayor

Jason Robards Sr.

Jason

Ernie Adams

Eben Bowen (uncredited)

Stanley Andrews

Ferguson (uncredited)

Jessie Arnold

Jason's Wife (uncredited)

Frank Austin

Farmer (uncredited)

Hank Bell

Townsman (uncredited)

Rudy Bowman

Townsman (uncredited)

Chet Brandenburg

Townsman (uncredited)

Ray Collins

Opening Narrator (voice) (uncredited)

William Desmond

Townsman (uncredited)

Kit Guard

Drunk (uncredited)

Lew Harvey

Henchman (uncredited)

Si Jenks

Charlie Thorne (uncredited)

Jack Kenny

Townsman (uncredited)

Donald Kerr

Townsman (uncredited)

Frank McGlynn Sr.

Tim McKeon (uncredited)

Robert Milasch

Townsman (uncredited)

Frank Mills

Townsman (uncredited)

Robert Emmett O'Connor

Drunk (uncredited)

Sarah Padden

Mrs. Ferguson (uncredited)

Harry 'Snub' Pollard

Farmer (uncredited)

Mickey Simpson

Man at Saloon Doors (uncredited)

Forrest Taylor

Dave (uncredited)

Sailor Vincent

Henchman (uncredited)

Blackjack Ward

Henchman (uncredited)