Errol Flynn

Dr. Peter Blood

Olivia de Havilland

Arabella Bishop

Lionel Atwill

Colonel Bishop

Basil Rathbone

Levasseur

Ross Alexander

Jeremy Pitt

Guy Kibbee

Hagthorpe

Henry Stephenson

Lord Willoughby

Robert Barrat

Wolverstone

Hobart Cavanaugh

Dr. Bronson

Donald Meek

Dr. Whacker

Jessie Ralph

Mrs. Barlow

Forrester Harvey

Honesty Nutall

Frank McGlynn Sr.

Reverend Ogle

Holmes Herbert

Capt. Gardner

David Torrence

Andrew Baynes

J. Carrol Naish

Cahusac

Pedro de Cordoba

Don Diego

George Hassell

Governor Steed

Matthew Beard

Governor's Attendant

Harry Cording

Kent

Leonard Mudie

Baron Jeffreys

Ivan F. Simpson

Prosecutor

Mary Forbes

Mrs. Steed

E. E. Clive

Clerk of the Court

Colin Kenny

Lord Chester Dyke

Gardner James

Slave

Vernon Steele

King James

Yola d'Avril

Girl in Tavern (uncredited)

Halliwell Hobbes

Lord Sunderland (uncredited)

Murray Kinnell

Court Clerk (uncredited)

Chris-Pin Martin

Sentry (uncredited)

James Pier Mason

Pirate (uncredited)

Louis Mercier

Pirate (uncredited)

Paul Panzer

Pirate (uncredited)

Frank Puglia

French Officer (uncredited)

Georges Renavent

French Captain (uncredited)

Jim Thorpe

Pirate (uncredited)