Paul Muni

Orin Nordholm Jr.

Aline MacMahon

Anna Nordholm

Mary Astor

Virginia Claffin Nordholm

Donald Cook

Richard Nordholm

Jean Muir

Selma Peterson / Granddaughter Selma

Guy Kibbee

James Claffin

Mickey Rooney

Otto Peterson as a Child

Patricia Ellis

Natalie Clifton Nordholm

Theodore Newton

Paul Nordholm

Margaret Lindsay

Jennifer Nordholm

Gordon Westcott

John Nordholm

Henry O'Neill

Orin Nordholm Sr.

William Janney

Orin Nordholm III

Douglass Dumbrille

Buffalo Bill Cody

Alan Mowbray

Sir Philip Ivor

Sidney Toler

Mr. Hodgens

Anna Q. Nilsson

Mrs. Peterson

Arthur Hohl

Mr. Patten

Alan Dinehart

Ogden Jarrett

Oscar Apfel

Mr. Morley, a Banker

Wallis Clark

Mr. Freddie McCord, a Clerk

Clay Clement

Lt. Col. George Armstrong Custer

William Burress

Mr. Krauss, a Banker

Marjorie Gateson

Mrs. Clinton

James Bush

Orin III's Roommate (uncredited)

George Chandler

Piano Player (uncredited)

Philip Faversham

Nordholm's Clerk (uncredited)

John Elliott

A Banker (uncredited)

Mary Gordon

Lady at Party (uncredited)

Howard Hickman

Doctor (uncredited)

Samuel S. Hinds

A Banker (uncredited)

Milton Kibbee

Organist at Wedding (uncredited)

Marilyn Knowlden

Young Selma (uncredited)

Wallace MacDonald

Sir Phillip's Best Man (uncredited)

Robert McKenzie

Townsman (uncredited)

Lew Meehan

Trooper (uncredited)

Charles Middleton

Sheriff Wild Bill Hickok (uncredited)

Dave O'Brien

Otto Peterson (uncredited)

Richard Quine

Young Richard (uncredited)

Jackie Searl

Young John (uncredited)

Larry Steers

Tourist (uncredited)

Sidney Toler

Mr. Hodgens, a Banker (uncredited)

Walter Walker

Doctor (uncredited)

Leo White

Panicked Investor (uncredited)

Pat Wing

Richard Nordholm's Secretary (uncredited)

Harry Woods

Sam (uncredited)

Tammany Young

Tour Guide (uncredited)