Rosario Dawson

Maya

Chad Faust

Jared

Vanessa Ferlito

Bodega Girl

Jonathan Neil Schneider

Archeology Professor

Nicole Vicius

Melanie

Colombe Jacobsen-Derstine

Nadia

Charlie Hewson

Usher

Rachael Leigh Cook

Allison

Spencer Grammer

Stephanie

Kristen Ruhlin

Maya's Friend from High School

James A. Stephens

Professor Byron

Paul Sado

Downstairs Guy

Scott Bailey

Upstairs Guy

Tracie Thoms

Denise

Alexie Gilmore

Seline

Johnathan Tchaikovsky

Tyler

Aisleagh Jackson

Construction Girl

Scott Porter

Brooks

Jacqueline Duprey

Celeste

Wilson Jermaine Heredia

Diego

Tommy Guiffre

Danny

Aaron Staton

Jared's Friend

Matthew J. Walters

Tim Banks

Peter Bongiorno

Football Coach

Adam Mucci

Football Player

Phoebe Strole

Innocent Girl

Kevin Cannon

Gruff Hood

Melissa Fumero

Dorm Girl

Aran Bertetto

Grad Student (uncredited)