Paul Muni

Eddie Kagle / Judge Fredrick Parker

Anne Baxter

Barbara Foster

Claude Rains

"Nick"

Onslow Stevens

Dr. Matt Higgins

George Cleveland

Albert

Erskine Sanford

Minister

Marion Martin

Rosie Morgan Bentley

Hardie Albright

"Smiley" Williams

James Flavin

Dan Bellamy

Murray Alper

Jim - Taxicab Driver (uncredited)

Sam Ash

Citizen (uncredited)

Chet Brandenburg

Man in Audience (uncredited)

Maurice Cass

Lucius (uncredited)

Chester Clute

Kramer (uncredited)

Jimmy Dime

Guard of Stokers in Hell (uncredited)

Eddie Dunn

Motorcycle Cop (uncredited)

Joel Friedkin

Malvola (uncredited)

Sol Gorss

Gangster (uncredited)

Jonathan Hale

Citizens for Better Government Chairman (uncredited)

Noble Johnson

Trustee in Hell (uncredited)

Kurt Katch

Warden in Hell (uncredited)

Edward Keane

Prison Yard Captain (uncredited)

Kenner G. Kemp

Lawyer at Table (uncredited)

Mike Lally

Gangster (uncredited)

Fritz Leiber

Chemist Who Poisoned Wife (uncredited)

Carl M. Leviness

Citizen (uncredited)

Wilbur Mack

Lawyer's Aide (uncredited)

George Meeker

Mr. Bentley (uncredited)

Harold Miller

Lawyer's Aide (uncredited)

William H. O'Brien

Court Spectator (uncredited)

Sarah Padden

Agatha (uncredited)

Addison Richards

Big Harry (uncredited)

Frank J. Scannell

Taxi Driver (uncredited)

Lee Shumway

Bailiff (uncredited)

Ray Spiker

Stoker Guard in Hell (uncredited)

Arthur Tovey

Court Spectator (uncredited)

Archie Twitchell

Police Sergeant (uncredited)

Ben Welden

Shaggsy (uncredited)