Victor Mature

Shelley Martin

Richard Egan

Boyd Fairchild

Stephen McNally

Harper

Virginia Leith

Linda Sherman

Tommy Noonan

Harry Reeves, Bank Manager

Lee Marvin

Dill

Margaret Hayes

Mrs. Emily Fairchild

J. Carrol Naish

Chapman, Bank Robber

Sylvia Sidney

Elsie Braden

Ernest Borgnine

Stadt, Amish Farmer

Dorothy Patrick

Helen Martin

Billy Chapin

Steve Martin

Brad Dexter

Gil Clayton

Robert Adler

Stan (uncredited)

John Alderson

Amish Farmer on Train (uncredited)

Virginia Carroll

Carol, Martin's Secretary (uncredited)

Harry Carter

Bart, Policeman (uncredited)

Kevin Corcoran

David Stadt (uncredited)

Noreen Corcoran

Anna Stadt (uncredited)

Ralph Dumke

Hotel Desk Clerk (uncredited)

Richard Garrick

Mr. Braden (uncredited)

Raymond Greenleaf

Mr. Fairchild (uncredited)

Robert Ivers

Caddy, at Country Club (uncredited)

Helen Mayon

Mrs. Pilka (uncredited)

Boyd 'Red' Morgan

Slick (uncredited)

Ann Morrison

Mrs. Martha Stadt (uncredited)

Robert Osterloh

Roy, Bartender (uncredited)

Dorothy Phillips

Bank Customer (uncredited)

Esther Somers

Amish Woman on Train (uncredited)

Jeri Weil

Amish Child on Train (uncredited)

Mack Williams

Drugstore Clerk (uncredited)