Alexander Molony

Peter Pan

Ever Anderson

Wendy Darling

Jude Law

James Hook

Yara Shahidi

Tinker Bell

Alyssa Wapanatâhk

Tiger Lily

Jim Gaffigan

Sam "Smee" Smiegel

Joshua Blue Pickering

John Darling

Jacobi Jupe

Michael Darling

Alan Tudyk

George Darling

Molly Parker

Mary Darling

Florence Bensberg

Curly

Sebastian Billingsley-Rodriguez

Nibs

Noah Matthews Matofsky

Slightly

Caelan Edie

Tootles

Kelsey Yates

Twin

Skyler Yates

Twin

Diana Tsoy

Birdie

Felix de Sousa

Bellweather

John DeSantis

Bill Jukes

Garfield Wilson

Gurley

Ian Tracey

Sallyport

Mark Acheson

Old Clemson

Jesse James Pierce

Skylight

Gemita Samarra

Mermaid

Cassie Van Wolde

Wendy Darling (Adult)

Deborah Ramsay

Wendy Darling (Old)

Paloma Nuñez

Starkey

Paul Cheng

Scrimshaw Sam

Mike Ching

Dirtbag Benny

Nick Preston

Pirate Chorus Member

Tony Chris Kazoleas

Pirate Chorus Member

Boyd Ferguson

Gundeck Pirate

Atlin Mitchell

Jolly Roger Pirate

Chad Bellamy

Jolly Roger Pirate

Darryl Quon

Jolly Roger Pirate

Fraser Aitcheson

Jolly Roger Pirate

Jason Day

Jolly Roger Pirate

Joshua Mazerolle

Jolly Roger Pirate

Todd Allen Johnson

Jolly Roger Pirate

Curtis Braconnier

Skull Rock Pirate

Brad Kelly

Skull Rock Pirate

Marshall Bingham

Skull Rock Pirate

Angela Uyeda

Skull Rock Pirate

Jack Kingsley

Jolly Roger Pirate / Skull Rock Pirate

Mark Krysko

Jolly Roger Pirate / Skull Rock Pirate

Lars Grant

Jolly Roger Pirate / Skull Rock Pirate

Danny Hospes

Jolly Roger Pirate / Gangly Pirate

Chanelle Hunter

Peter's Shadow