Armand Assante

Jack Saxon

Justin Baldoni

Barry Minkow

Talia Shire

Carol Minkow

Mark Hamill

Robert Minkow

Gianni Russo

Derek Lewis

Elisabeth Röhm

Lisa Minkow

Michael Nouri

Uncle Joe

Ving Rhames

Peanut

James Caan

Agent Gamble

Scott Patterson

Older Mike

Anastacia McPherson

Diana

Mike O'Hearn

Mr. Green

Blake Berris

Young Mike (as Blake Barris)

Kelly Noonan

Reporter #1

Ragan Brooks

Aida

Gavin Houston

Hulking Jock

Nicole Travolta

Gail Minkow

Bill Goldberg

Victor

Robin Thomas

Mr. Fitzgerald

Andy Milder

Mr. Hall

Robert Pine

Judge

Nicolas Coster

Don Scott

David Hutchison

Inmate

Kent Shocknek

Reporter

Waymond Lee

Churchgoer

David Fernandez Jr.

Inmate

Stephen Snedden

Smooth

Christopher Kriesa

Parole Board Officer

Ali Costello

Valerie

Margarita Reyes

Grace

Caroline Fogarty

Assistant

Liz Jenkins

Amy

Suzanne LaChasse

Office Worker

Melissa Ordway

Mindy (uncredited)

Paleigh Knight

Little Girl

Rene Napoli

FBI Agent