Nina Dobrev

Elizabeth Daniels

Vanessa Hudgens

Tara

Adam Pally

Dax

Eva Longoria

Grace Chapman

Rob Corddry

Kurt Chapman

Tone Bell

Jimmy Johnston

Jon Bass

Garrett

Michael Cassidy

Dr. Mike Stone

Finn Wolfhard

Tyler

Ron Cephas Jones

Walter

Thomas Lennon

Greg

Tig Notaro

Danielle Thornhill

Lauren Lapkus

Daisy

Jessica St. Clair

Ruth

Ryan Hansen

Peter

Tony Cavalero

Stanley

Elizabeth Phoenix Caro

Amelia Chapman

Jessica Lowe

Amy

Mo Gaffney

Mayor Velez

Jasmine Cephas Jones

Lola

Casey Deidrick

Jude

Phoebe Neidhardt

Alexa

John Gemberling

Ernie

Arielle Vandenberg

Kristen

Toks Olagundoye

Nina

Ken Marino

Carven Wagi

David Wain

Wacky Wayne

Megan Park

Kelli

Matt Cordova

Ben

Gina Ward

Addie

Joseph Bezenek

Baby Shower Husband (uncredited)