Billy Eichner

Bobby

Luke Macfarlane

Aaron

Guy Branum

Henry

Miss Lawrence

Wanda

Dot-Marie Jones

Cherry

Jim Rash

Robert

Eve Lindley

Tamara

Monica Raymund

Tina

Guillermo Díaz

Edgar

Jai Rodriguez

Jason

Amanda Bearse

Anne

Debra Messing

Debra Messing

Peter Y. Kim

Peter

Justin Covington

Paul

Symone

Marty

Ryan Faucett

Josh

Becca Blackwell

Lucas

D'Lo

Tom

Harvey Fierstein

Louis

Bowen Yang

Lawrence Grape

Derrick Delgado

Brian

George Dvorsky

Bruce

Jamyl Dobson

Joel

Brock Ciarlelli

Steve

Kenan Thompson

James Baldwin

Amy Schumer

Eleanor Roosevelt

Jillian Gottlieb

Samantha

Rick Crom

Grape's Neighbor

Everett Quinton

Melvin Funk

Julia Scotti

Straight Older Woman

Nanie Méndez

Party Guest

William Popp

Pride Awards Football Player

Aidan Wharton

Football Player

Kristin Chenoweth

Kristin Chenoweth

Alex Ringler

Baseball Player's Man

Shannon O'Neill

Paula

Matthew Wilkas

Handsome Grindr Guy

Ben Stiller

Ben Stiller (uncredited)

Seth Meyers

Harvey Milk (uncredited)

Anthony DeVito

Straight Liberal Dad (uncredited)