Rosario Dawson

Gabbie

Chase W. Dillon

Travis

LaKeith Stanfield

Ben Matthias

Owen Wilson

Father Kent

Tiffany Haddish

Harriet

Danny DeVito

Bruce Davis

Jared Leto

The Hatbox Ghost

Jamie Lee Curtis

Madame Leota

J.R. Adduci

William Gracey

Creek Wilson

Mariner Ghost

Lindsay Lamb

The Bride

Charity Jordan

Alyssa

Fedor Steer

Ezra

Terence Rosemore

Phineas

Mike Benitez

Gus

Erika Coleman

Eleanor Gracey

Christopher Winchester

New Year's Eve Bartender

Jo Koy

Daytime Bartender

Gralen Bryant Banks

Drunk Man

Marilu Henner

Carol Tourist

Steve Zissis

Roger

Andrew Morgado

TV Narrator (voice)

Amy Parrish

Doctor

Kurt Yue

Police Officer

Hasan Minhaj

Sketch Artist

Dan Levy

Vic

Rowan Joseph

Male Tour Guest

Alisa Harris

Female Tour Guest

Sebastien Soudais

Duelist

John Curran

Pickwick

Tracy Goode

Executioner

Bryan McClure

Headless Knight

Don Stallings

Venetian Ghost

Rick Andosca

Caretaker Ghost

Kamran Shaikh

Suited Man on Dynamite

Jared Simon

Hatted Man in Quicksand

Ian Covell

Quicksand Man

Kay Galvin

Elderly Woman w/Rose

Winona Ryder

Pat (uncredited)

Keiko Bell

Nurse (uncredited)