Paul Rudd

George

Jennifer Aniston

Linda

Malin Akerman

Eva

Justin Theroux

Seth

Alan Alda

Carvin

Ken Marino

Rick

Joe Lo Truglio

Wayne

Kathryn Hahn

Karen

Kerri Kenney

Kathy

Lauren Ambrose

Almond

Michaela Watkins

Marisa

Jordan Peele

Rodney

Linda Lavin

Shari

Jessica St. Clair

Deena Schuster

Todd Barry

Sherm

Martin Thompson

Dale

Ian Patrick

Grisham

John D'Leo

Tanner

David Wain

Himself

Michael Showalter

Himself

Michael Ian Black

Himself

Zandy Hartig

Marcy

Keegan-Michael Key

Marcy’s Flunkie

Mather Zickel

Jim Stansel

Juan Piedrahita

Paco

Peter Salett

Manfreddie

Patricia French

Beverly

Nina Hellman

Protester

Richard Allan Jones

Jerry Beaver

Juana Samayoa

Stephanie Davis

Craig Wedren

The Elysium Band Member

Ray Liotta

Ray Liotta (uncredited)

Trisha Paytas

Davidson's Wife (uncredited)

Ron Raines

Shari's Partner (uncredited)

Rosemary Howard

Manhattan Pedestrian (uncredited)

Nina Nayebi

Woman at Casino Table (uncredited)

Katherine Neslund

Concerned Citizen (uncredited)

Joel Rogers

Minivan Freeway Driver (uncredited)